As I continue to grow my fan base, I suspect many of the people likely to be interested in my music, and many Classical music fans in general, will be somewhat older (40+). I have received polite expressions of concern in the past from older fans who may be less tech-savvy than all of us, and for whom even a simple email autoresponder series may be a barrier to entry. One supporter politely explained how it took her two weeks to regain access to her PayPal account (previously registered in a now-defunct bank account) to purchase my digital album, while another older couple expressed sincere interest in the work but asked for a CD in the mail, adding that "Dave hates to buy stuff online." In previous years with Kickstarter campaigns, I have faced similar polite expressions of confusion and frustration from well-meaning older users.
I remember learning that one of the first rules in business is don't try to change your customer. With this in mind, am I crazy to consider starting a "snail mail" autoresponder series?
Obviously this entails more financial risk than email autoresponder series, but perhaps not to an impossible extent. A CD single in a sleeve for the first autoresponder might be $1-2, depending. 6 subsequent mailed letters (including postage) will cost roughly $3.00 total, if my math is correct. If I ask for $10 for my album (payable as a check in the mail), a return of $10 for a $5 investment is not a bad ROI.
Obviously I can't count on every subscriber buying my CD, but I wonder if a fringe benefit of using snail mail might be higher conversion rates. Perhaps people will be more responsive to the obvious effort and investment required to send 6 letters by mail, as opposed to 6 emails. Additionally, many older people who may be suspicious of Internet purchases should be perfectly comfortable with paying by mail with a check, and many for whom mp3's are a foreign concept may have well-stocked record and CD collections and are more comfortable listening to recorded music on these formats.
Right now my biggest question is finding a tidy way to collect snail mail addresses. I currently use MailChimp for my email autoresponder series and am designing a sign up box with spaces for snail mail info. I have also recently discovered postable.com which offers similar snail mail collecting services. There may be some more potential pitfalls to consider but I look forward to testing this idea soon.
Has anyone ever tried a snail mail campaign before? Anyone find that people are more or less likely to give out their snail mail addresses versus their email addresses?
Thanks for any thoughts.
Ezra
Hey Ezra,
The thinking isn't crazy. What you are describing is how they did it back in the days before email. It's actually direct response marketing 101.
That said, I would personally stay away from it for now. It's infinitely more complex and expensive. It's the kind of thing you could play with AFTER you had your numbers dialed in with email.
I really wouldn't take those occasional remarks too seriously. It's true that a certian percentage of people feel that way, but there have been countless tests done by marketers that show that despite all the complaints about buying online, paypal, etc... If people want it, they mostly buy it. Regardless of the fact that classical is an older demo. You could always just bring your age range down if you were really concerned.
Long story short, if you can't dial your numbers in with an online campaign, i don't think going offline will solve your problem.
Hope that helps.
Having trouble with your marketing? Wish you could have an experienced direct-to-fan marketing expert look over your actual campaigns, music, or content and offer feedback? Or perhaps you’re just looking for a little one-on-one assistance so you can ask questions that pertain to your specific goals and get a second, more experienced, perspective? Click here to book a session with me now.
Hi Ezra,
Snail mail is still used to this day by a fair amount of direct response marketers. However I only ever seem to get direct mail from marketers that I've purchased from previously. In other words, I'm not sure this is the kind of thing you would want to do with general prospects, but if you've got something to offer that is perhaps a bit pricier than the normal offer, direct mail might be a good way to personally reach out to your customers.
That said, you can always ask for a customer's postal address, as they complete paypal checkout. You would just have to turn on the setting to ask for it during the checkout process, even though the customers are purchasing a digital product.
Like John mentioned though, this can be costly, so if you want to see a decent ROI, there likely has to be a higher-ticketed offer attached to the mail campaign that helps offset the cost for those who do not respond to it.
On a side note, I once was a subscriber to a marketer who did direct mail for free by finding other marketers to go in on the direct mail campaign with him, essentially nullifying his own personal cost altogether. Something to think about anyway.
-Steve